James Gallery & Soda Fountain

Lafayette, Katherine Hepburn… And Me
Old Saybrook, July 25, 2009

I first became aware of this little shop with a fascinating history when picking off places along the Connecticut Freedom Trail. Sure, the piece of the building’s history that qualifies it for that trail is interesting enough – but there’s much, much more.


And to top it off, the Soda Fountain itself is historic, quaint – and operational! Old timey pharmacy (check), old timey soda fountain (check), famous visitors (check), interesting history (check), idyllic locale (check)… Yeah, this place is pretty darn cool.

The following text is from the Pratt House B&B website, who now own and manage the property.

“Built in 1790, the James Pharmacy was originally the general store for the Humphrey Pratt Tavern, Old Saybrook’s Inn of yesteryear. Humphrey Pratt was the brother of Deacon Timothy Pratt, who built the house next door, The Deacon Timothy Pratt Bed and Breakfast.

jpc.jpgIt is said that Marquis de Lafayette, friend of George Washington and Revolutionary War hero, stopped at the store in 1824, to make a purchase. It is local legend that the purchase was either a pair of socks or a bar of saddle soap. Katharine Hepburn also took a liking to the general store; she used to stop in to make telephone calls from the old oak phone booth.

The store was first located further down Main Street, adjacent to the tavern, until it was moved to the corner of Pennywise Lane in 1877, where it became a pharmacy. Peter Lane added the soda fountain portion of the pharmacy in 1896. When Peter was called away to fight in World War I, he left the care of what was then the Lane Pharmacy with his sister-in-law, Anna Louise James.

jpd.jpgMiss James, as she was known to all, was born on January 19, 1886 in Hartford Connecticut. Her family later moved to Old Saybrook where she grew up. In 1908, Miss James was the first African American woman to graduate from the Brooklyn College of Pharmacy, thus making her the first female African American pharmacist in the state of Connecticut. Miss James ran the pharmacy from 1917 until 1967, and kept residence in the back apartment until her death in 1977.

The store itself was vacant from Miss James’ retirement in 1967 until 1980, when it was revamped and opened again in 1984. The soda fountain still holds the charm and wonder of Miss James, boasting an original Miss James Sundae, as well as the original cabinetry, tables and chairs with heart shaped backs, as well as the original Vermont marble countertops. The milkshake maker, circa 1940, is also from the Miss James era.

jpa.jpgIn the early 1990′s, the Pharmacy was in a commercial done by AT&T, as well as part of a documentary about Katharine Hepburn. Ann Lane Petry, Miss James’ niece and also a registered pharmacist, worked for Miss James and spent a lot of time at the pharmacy. Ann is better known for her writing skills and has published six books, some of which have won her both local and international fame, including The Drug Store Cat, based on her memories of the pharmacy when she was growing up and Country Place, a novel based on her experiences living in Old Saybrook. She is most well known for her novel The Street, a Houghton Mifflin Literary Fellowship book. All of Ann’s publications are on display in the gallery area of the pharmacy. Today we try to bring history alive by displaying original artifacts from the pharmacy and serving old-fashioned favorites from the historic soda fountain as well as gourmet coffees.”

jpb.jpgWow. I wonder how many people stop in for an ice cream cone and have absolutely no idea about any of that stuff. Well, there is a sign out front declaring “Lafayette bought something here” – which is pretty funny to me. With all the “Washington Slept Here’s” dotting the state, a “Lafayette bought socks here” is somehow more interesting to me.

Hoang enjoyed an old fashioned milkshake; actually, Damian downed half of it – and I just a cup of chocolate raspberry truffle. The parlor room was stiflingly hot, but that only added to the authenticity.

History is everywhere.

Closed Mon.; Tues.-Fri.3-8pm; Sat.12- 9pm ;Sun. 12-8pm. (hours vary off season)

Leave a Comment

The Out Campaign: Scarlet Letter of Atheism